Alone we can do so little
Together we can do so much


Want a face-to-face interaction?  You can have that with us.  We are located in downtown Paw Paw and enjoy our central location that makes it easy for customers to visit whenever needed.


We have built strong relationships with some of the best insurance providers in the United States and can offer you many options because of our strong networking.


We know that every one of our customers is first and foremost a human being. We are empathetic to your situations and will work our hardest to solve your insurance problems.

Who we are

McKenzie Insurance in an independent agency owned and operated by a local family for three generations, offering red carpet service since 1945. McKenzie Insurance is in the business of protecting the assets of many Michigan individuals, families, and businesses. Whether you are a large business or an individual seeking to cover your life, home, or automobiles, we have the resources and expertise to meet your needs. The McKenzie Insurance Agency is a firm of proven professionals who are kind, caring, and dependable. We’ve earned our reputation by giving special attention to other’s needs. We understand simple, cost-effective coverage relieves stress for both individuals and businesses. We stand by your side and make insurance easy for you.

Real People You can trust

Randy McKenzie

Owner, Insurance Agent

Randy is the third generation owner of McKenzie Insurance Agency. He is a graduate of Ferris State University with a degree in insurance. Out of college he began his insurance career as a claims adjuster for various companies over a 10+ year time span. In 2007, Randy became a licensed insurance agent and joined his dad Tom McKenzie where he spent time learning his customers and their insurance needs.

Jodee Smith

Insurance Agent

Jodee joined McKenzie Insurance in 2013. She lives with her husband and two children. Choosing a career in the insurance industry helps fulfill her need to help people. Licensed to sell insurance since 2005, she continues to keep up with insurance standards and continuing education. Jodee can help you with all your insurance needs.

Brad McKenzie

Insurance Agent

Brad came to McKenzie Insurance in 2019, after 30 years in the culinary industry as an Executive Chef. His love for his family and friends brought him to the insurance industry. Brad and Mar have two daughters and one grandson who they love to spoil. If you see him on the weekend, it will be behind the wheel of his car cruising with his wife searching for the next good restaurant to dine-in. Working closely with his brother he was able to become a licensed insurance agent. Brad prides himself on sharing his knowledge of insurance with his clients. If you ask, he may even share a tip or two for that next big meal you are planning!!

Lisa Herr

Customer Service Representative

Lisa joined McKenzie Insurance in 2021. A graduate of Central Michigan University with a degree in Interpersonal & Public Communication. She lives with her husband and two children. On her down time, you may find her camping with her family and spending time with her friends. She has over 30 years in customer service working with the steel industry, and specialty company that dealt with government, pharmaceutical, medical, and educational facilities. McKenzie Insurance Agency provides Lisa with the career in promoting and maintaining relationships with our customers. As a Customer Care Representative, Lisa will assist you with your insurance servicing, billing, and claims.